The attacks of October 7, 2023, in Israel were not the result of a single mistake, but of a chain of failures that came together with devastating effect. Israel placed too much confidence in its technology, believing that sensors, cameras, and automated systems along the border could replace the need for soldiers and a strong forward presence. That false sense of security left entire communities exposed when the attack came. For the United States, the lesson is clear: technology is a tool, not a shield. It must be backed by people on the ground, rapid-reaction forces, and leadership that understands the limits of machines.
Another key failure was the steady loss of human intelligence inside Gaza. Without trusted sources on the ground, Israel could not see the full scope of the enemy’s plans. Analysts were left piecing together fragments, and critical warning signs were missed. America is already sliding into the same trap. In both Syria and Afghanistan, we have allowed our intelligence networks to wither, leaning instead on information provided by the very regimes and terrorist-linked actors who control those areas. By outsourcing our understanding to unreliable or hostile sources, we blind ourselves to the enemy’s intent and allow them space to prepare.
Division within Israel also played a role. Protests, political turmoil, and deep polarization weakened national unity and distracted leaders, creating openings that adversaries were quick to exploit. Social fractures became a security vulnerability, not just a political challenge. Polarization is not just politics; it is a national security threat. Here, we are already seeing worrying signs, particularly on college campuses and social media, where some younger Americans have adopted openly pro-terrorist narratives, glorifying groups like Hamas. This represents an erosion of moral clarity that adversaries will exploit to weaken our resolve and divide our society from within.
Local communities near Gaza were also left defenseless because the civilian security squads had been steadily weakened over the years. These rapid-response teams, made up of local residents with military training, were meant to be the first line of defense in the event of an infiltration. Yet many had their heavier weapons removed, their budgets cut, and their training neglected, based on the belief that border fences, cameras, and sensors would make large-scale incursions impossible. On October 7, that assumption proved deadly. When Hamas and allied foreign fighters stormed across the border, many of these squads had only a handful of rifles to defend entire communities. For Americans, the warning is simple: community-level preparedness matters.
Training and doctrine were also misaligned. Israel trained for small raids and limited attacks, not the kind of large-scale, multi-front, complex attack that took place. For the United States, this is a warning to prepare for the unthinkable. Exercises must simulate multiple simultaneous attackers across dispersed locations, hostage scenarios, communications blackouts, and mass-casualty surges to hospitals. Community members must be included in these preparations, not left on the sidelines.
It is also worth remembering what did not happen. Hezbollah’s Radwan forces on the northern border chose not to join the October 7 attack. Had they done so, the casualties and hostage crisis would have been many times worse. This near miss shows the importance of planning for escalation and worst-case scenarios. We cannot assume enemies will act alone or hold back.
Finally, the voices of Israel’s reservists and junior soldiers were ignored. For years, they warned of poor training, inadequate equipment, insufficient body armor, limited armored transport and night vision, degraded communications, and a lack of readiness for war, yet their concerns were dismissed. America must not repeat this mistake. Those on the front lines must be able to raise alarms and leaders must take them seriously before it is too late. Today, many of our own veterans are also sounding similar warnings. Drawing on decades of experience fighting terrorists, they see the same flashing red lights for a homeland attack, yet too often their expertise is brushed aside.
The lessons of October 7th are clear and urgent. Hubris, overconfidence, blind spots, division, and ignored warnings can lead to disaster. To honor the victims, including the more than 40 Americans who were killed, we must learn from these failures. The United States cannot depend on technology alone, cannot ignore human intelligence, and cannot let division weaken us. We must stay prepared, united, and vigilant to avoid being caught off guard as the next target.